I am going to Edale to shoot a 3min silent film with a partner in one week after being given a very vague brief and the option do do anything as long as it has something to do with Portrait of Place and is filmed in Edale (which is a small country village nothing special, we googled it). I began working in a group of three and we brainstormed some ideas:
Idea 1!
Just a view of the landscapes and towns. However without sound the still or slow pan images might not be very interesting and it would be unchallenging to say the least.
Idea 2!
My first initial idea was to do something with still or slow pan images like in idea one but with a symbolic meaning woven into the subtext like in most films. Still camera and visual wise not very interesting, back to the drawing board....
Idea 3
Begin the film with an extreme everything, extreme: close up, camera movements, editing, angles, colour. Then after doing a few crazy images begin to calm the images in all ways until the end of the short where the shot is still black and white ELS, a classic landscape shot. I liked this idea but I felt although it stretched filming and camera work talent it was uncreative and uninteresting. Soooo how could this be made more interesting??? My partners suggested cutting up the sequence and juxtaposing the close up with the far away to make it seem more abstract and experimental.
Idea 4!
To film small objects maybe 5 different small objects or ECU's of large objects and then do the technique from Idea 3 on each and then we have lots of different shots to juxtapose together. We then started thinking of objects to put in like tree bark in the woody areas and maybe rubbish or post boxes in the town section. We also decided after the crazily edited section we would show the whole process in order quickly to satisfy the viewers curiosity about what the ECU's were of.
Idea 5!
My partners then suggested we use something that at first would contrast the later image for example a pretty flower, then finally a pretty flower in a cemetery, that would make the audience think twice about the connotations of such common things. However we weren't sure if we were fulfilling the brief of Portrait of Place... That got me thinking...
Idea 6!
To use things that contrasted the town in general completely so what is the opposite of a quiet little countryside village with stone walls and free wildlife..... Then it struck me I could layer in some of my personal Sci Fi interests as well as possibly some political subtext by introducing technology as the contrasting element to Edale. I asked my group what they though and it seemed a good idea, new ideas and though spread from it, what technology to use and where would contrast the technology the most. An idea cam up a great one a title:
It seemed fitting and we were happy with our idea.
However when we pitched it back to our lecturer it seemed to get lost in translation a little and his advice was to stick with the idea of contrast visually but the technology thing wasn't strongly anchored enough to make sense to a viewer. I personally would like viewers of this short to activley engage and try to figure out the link as through more thought I have begun a further stage of planning on this idea however taking into consideration the idea of soing some preliminary shooting aswell as trying to anchor the image further. He also suggested using colour as a contrast instead however until another idea is thought of I will be thinking of ways to use colour to enhance the contrast within the technology idea. I am going to research what extreme technological things we could use or even create that would seem real but again contrast the natural world even more. The feedback criticism has made me begin thinking on other areas of contrast but mainly just persuaded me to attempt to tell this loose meaning through images alone. Why? Because I think it is really fitting to use an opposite to what something is to show it in a light and although I don't know Edale the idea of the large landscapes washing out the small pieces of technology as they get duller and duller really seems like strong symbolic image and message to me...... Or it could be back to the drawing board, only time will tell.